Pam, here is the comments on the one page, to use for the final paper. See attached documents for rubric.
This version looks a lot better! Your grade on it is 4/5.
If you are wanting to use this for your final paper, make sure to explain what is meant by a pointless evil. Rowe’s argument focuses on this, so you need to explain what it is and why Rowe finds these types of evils especially objectionable. The
best way would be to explain why Rowe accepts each premise individually. So, tell me why Rowe thinks God would prevent pointless evil, what pointless evil is, and why Rowe thinks it exists.
Let me know if you have any questions.”